BMW 1 series 2009 vs Mercedes CLK 2005
| Gearbox: | Manual | Manual | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Engine: | 2.0 Diesel | 1.8 Petrol | |
| Diesel (BMW 1 series) engines typically outperform gasoline engines in terms of fuel efficiency and low-end torque. This makes them more economical and better suited for towing or long-distance travel. However, gasoline (Mercedes CLK) engines mostly are lighter, quieter, and offer better acceleration and responsiveness, especially in smaller vehicles. For more information, see the article "Diesel or Petrol: Fuel Economy and Key Differences." | |||
| Camshaft drive: | Timing chain | Timing chain | |
Performance | |||
| Power: | 143 HP | 163 HP | |
| Torque: | 300 NM | 240 NM | |
| Acceleration 0-100 km/h: | 9 seconds | 9.3 seconds | |
|
BMW 1 series is more dynamic to drive. BMW 1 series engine produces 20 HP less power than Mercedes CLK, but torque is 60 NM more than Mercedes CLK. Despite less power, BMW 1 series reaches 100 km/h speed 0.3 seconds faster. | |||
Fuel consumption | |||
| Fuel consumption (l/100km): | 4.5 | 8.3 | |
| Real fuel consumption: | 5.7 l/100km | 8.7 l/100km | |
|
The BMW 1 series is a better choice when it comes to fuel economy. By specification BMW 1 series consumes 3.8 litres less fuel per 100 km than the Mercedes CLK, which means that by driving the BMW 1 series over 15,000 km in a year you can save 570 litres of fuel. By comparing actual fuel consumption based on user reports, BMW 1 series consumes 3 litres less fuel per 100 km than the Mercedes CLK. | |||
| Fuel tank capacity: | 51 litres | 62 litres | |
| Full fuel tank distance: | 1130 km in combined cycle | 740 km in combined cycle | |
| 890 km with real consumption | 710 km with real consumption | ||
| BMW 1 series gets more mileage on one fuel tank. | |||
| Read the article "Fuel Efficiency: How to Reduce Fuel Consumption" to learn more about fuel economy. | |||
Engines | |||
| Average engine lifespan: | 350'000 km | 440'000 km | |
| Engine resource depends largely on regular maintenance and the quality of the oils and fuels used, but under equal conditions the average life of a Mercedes CLK engine could be longer. | |||
| Engine production duration: | 18 years | 13 years | |
| Engine spread: | Installed on at least 6 other car models, including BMW 5 sērija, BMW 3 sērija, BMW X3, BMW X1 | Installed on at least 3 other car models, including Mercedes C klase, Mercedes E klase, Mercedes SLK | |
| In general, the longer and for more car models an engine is produced, the better its serviceability and availability of spare parts. BMW 1 series might be a better choice in this respect. | |||
| BMW 1 sērija 2009 2.0 engine: The BMW N47 engine is sometimes called the worst BMW engine because of problems with the timing chain, which tends to stretch at 100 000 km. In addition, the engine has to be removed from the car to replace ... More about BMW 1 sērija 2009 2.0 engine Mercedes CLK 2005 1.8 engine: The most notable issue with this engine is the sticking of exhaust valves due to carbon buildup. Another significant problem is the unreliable timing chain, which can stretch by 100,000 km. Early symptoms of a ... More about Mercedes CLK 2005 1.8 engine | |||
Dimensions | |||
| Length: | 4.36 m | 4.65 m | |
| Width: | 1.75 m | 1.74 m | |
| Height: | 1.42 m | 1.41 m | |
| BMW 1 series is 29 cm shorter than the Mercedes CLK, 1 cm wider, while the height of BMW 1 series is 1 cm higher. | |||
| Trunk capacity: | 370 litres | 435 litres | |
|
Mercedes CLK has more luggage space. BMW 1 series has 65 litres less trunk space than the Mercedes CLK. | |||
| Turning diameter: | 10.7 meters | 10.8 meters | |
| The turning circle of the BMW 1 series is 0.1 metres less than that of the Mercedes CLK. | |||
| Power steering: | Electric power steering | Hydraulic power steering | |
| Electric power steering is simpler, quieter, more fuel-efficient, more configurable and provides additional features such as auto-steering for lane assist and parking. The disadvantages of electric power steering are possible overheating under prolonged load conditions and insufficient feedback (feeling) during steering. | |||
| Gross weight (kg): | 1`760 | 2`010 | |
| Safety: | no data | no data | |
| Quality: | BMW 1 series has fewer problems. According to annual technical inspection data Mercedes CLK has serious deffects in 200 percent more cases than BMW 1 series, so BMW 1 series quality is probably significantly better | ||
| Average price (€): | 5000 | 4200 | |
| Pros and Cons: |
BMW 1 sērija has
|
Mercedes CLK has
| |